Shop

Ty Plush Taffy Dog 1997 MWMT

$ 6.51 $ 3.9

TY Mystery the Classic Plush 1999 Dark Brown Standing Stuffed Realistic Siamese

$ 13.15 $ 7.89

Vintage Ty SAHARA LION Plush 1997 Stuffed Animal Toy MWMT

$ 5.5 $ 3.3

Rare, Vintage Ty Classic 15" Zulu the Zebra Plush Stuffed Animal 1993

$ 74.8 $ 44.88

Ty Classic NUZZLE Puppy Dog Dark Brown Chocolate Lab Plush TySilk 2001 Stuffed

$ 15.81 $ 9.48

TY Classic Beanie plush Lovie the Lamb 1997 Retired Plush 9"

$ 6.55 $ 3.93

Ty Beanie Buddies Classic "Bluebeary Bear" 15" Plush Multi Shades Blue 1999

$ 7.39 $ 4.43

Ty Classic SPARKLES the Unicorn 12" Plush MWMT Multicolored Mane & Tail

$ 8.52 $ 5.11

TY Vintage Jersey Cow Plush 11" H White With Brown 1996 with tag

$ 12.05 $ 7.23

Ty CLASSIC White Terrier Dog With Bandana 10 Inch Stuffed Toy 2007 (No Hang Tags

$ 2.2 $ 1.32

10" TY Classic Bean Plush Seated TAFFY Puppy Terrier Dog Stuffed Animal Lovey

$ 11.2 $ 6.72

TY "MANGO" Orangutan MONKEY WHITE 20”

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

Ty Classic / Plush "Presto" 2004 Bunny Rabbit 9" of Curly White Blue eyed Magic

$ 2.64 $ 1.58

TY Classic / Plush "Nibbles" Vintage 1993 Brown Bunny Rabbit 8"

$ 5.28 $ 3.16

TY classic bull dog SHEDDER 12" brown & white puppy w red collar & tag

$ 4.62 $ 2.77

TY CLASSIC PLUSH "JENKINS "2001 VINTAGE ,FANTASTIC CONDITION 🐶

$ 22.3 $ 13.38

White Angora Plush Kitten Cat Genevieve Blue Eyes 7" Long Body TY 2001 Retired

$ 28.16 $ 16.89

Vintage 1995 Ty French Bulldog Classic Beanie Buddies CHURCHILL Retired w/Tags

$ 15.83 $ 9.49

TY Classic Plush - BENGAL the Tiger (9 inch) - MWMTs Stuffed Animal Toy

$ 16.62 $ 9.97

TY 1990 Plush White & Black Cow with Udder 15" Rare!

$ 44 $ 26.4

TY Duchess Pink Cat Plush Gingham Bow

$ 16.89 $ 10.13

Vintage Ty Classic "SPARKLES" the White Unicorn with PINK Mane & Tail w/tag

$ 8.58 $ 5.14

Ty Classic Shanghai Panda Bear 2009 Plush Stuffed Animal 11" Black White Beanie

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

1997 Ty Spout The Elephant Plush 12" Stuffed Animal With Tag Vintage Gray Jungle

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

2005 TY CLASSIC 14" Plush BENGAL TIGER Striped Orange Black Stuffed Animal Toy

$ 14.95 $ 8.97

TY BEANIE BABY BLACK CAT EBONY 15" M PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL 1993 NWT TAG NEW

$ 14.91 $ 8.94

❤️2003 Ty Classic Calhoun Puppy Dog Tan Brown Shaggy Plush❤️

$ 0.87 $ 0.52

Ty Rumples Gold Teddy Bear Plush 1990 Handmade 16 inches #5002

$ 24.2 $ 14.52

Ty Classic LOVIE the Lamb 9" Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

$ 4.4 $ 2.64

Ty Beanie Buddies Classic Kicks Teddy Bear-14" Tall Retired

$ 11.22 $ 6.73

Genuine TY Lovie Lamb Collectible Stuffed Animal RETIRED - GREAT! WITH TAGS!!

$ 6.86 $ 4.11

Ty Classic Marcel French Bulldog Puppy Dog White Plush 9" Boston Terrier Toy

$ 11.43 $ 6.85

Ty Classic Bunny Rabbit Plush Buttons 10” Stuffed Animal 1997

$ 10.55 $ 6.33

Ty Classic TOASTY Teddy Bear w Scarf Cream Beige Curly Plush Stuffed 13" 2005 NW

$ 20.23 $ 12.13

2002 TY Classics Gorilla plush 10.5” silver brown RUMBLES

$ 8.8 $ 5.28

1987 TY Licorice Laying Black Persian Cat Plush

$ 26.4 $ 15.83

TY jointed bear Scruffy 16" soft & fluffy 1991

$ 6.16 $ 3.69

"Azure" Bear 1993 Attic Collections Beanie Baby

$ 66 $ 39.6

Hightops 2010 TY Classic Plush 14" Beanbag Tush TY Silk Giraffe LOVEY GUC

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

TY Beanie Buddies Plush Stuffed Cream Ivory Golden Lab MUFFIN 12” DOG Puppy

$ 18.69 $ 11.21

TY BEANIE BUDDIES BANANAS THE ORANGUTAN MONKEY 13" PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL 2000

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

VINTAGE 2001 TY CLASSIC THOMAS SNOW LEOPARD WILD CAT STUFFED PLUSH Large

$ 9.67 $ 5.8

RUSS BERRIE *** PRINCESS *** CAT STUFFED ANIMAL WITH TAG, 26 INCHES ** CLEAN **

$ 15.83 $ 9.49

Vintage 1991 TY 17" Weighted Curly Bunny Rabbit with Maroon Ribbon, Clean

$ 5.93 $ 3.55

Stuffed/plush toy animal Armidillo "Tank" Ty - Beanie Baby 1995

$ 7.87 $ 4.72

TY Classic / Plush "Lilypad" 2004 Spotted Frog 14" With Orange front & back feet

$ 4.4 $ 2.64

Ty Classic Blushed Giraffe Pink Red Hearts Plush Valentine Soft Toy 2006 Tags

$ 22 $ 13.2

17" TY Tulip the Pig Plush

$ 21.99 $ 13.19

Lot Retired TY Beanie Babies Cats Scat, Zip, Prance

$ 10.47 $ 6.28

13" TY Classic Plush TUMBLES Cat Designed by Sally Winey Style 1008

$ 16.71 $ 10.02

1987 TY Classic LICORICE CAT Black Persian 15" Plush Stuffed Lying Soft Toy Vtg

$ 30.36 $ 18.21

TY Classic Plush - CLOVER the White Rabbit (15 inch) - NWTs Stuffed Animal

$ 7.03 $ 4.21

Vintage 2002 TY INC Beanie Buddies Gray White Puppy Named Herder 11 x 8.5 Inches

$ 2.19 $ 1.31

TY Angel White Persian Cat Plush 1987 19" Kitty Style 1001 3rd Gen.

$ 13.2 $ 7.91

Ty Classic NUZZLE Dark Brown Plush Puppy Dog 2001 Mint 13" Approx. EUC

$ 11.44 $ 6.86

Ty Classic Beanbag Plush Gourdin Pumpkin Jack-O-Lantern 7" 2004

$ 17.58 $ 10.54

TY Classic Boots Black White Kitty Cat Plush Red Bow 1997 Stuffed Animal 1997

$ 17.67 $ 10.6

A137 Ty Classics Nuzzle Chocolate Lab Puppy Dog Plush 11" Stuffed Toy Lovey

$ 16.61 $ 9.96

Ty Classic "JEEVES" TEDDY BEAR Plush Retired Style #5038 Beanie Baby Mint Tag

$ 13.2 $ 7.91

Smokey Grey Cat 1999 Ty Classic Plush Persian 16" Kitten Gold Eyes Fluffy

$ 28.99 $ 17.39

Ty Collectibles Lily the Lamb stuffed animal

$ 14.08 $ 8.44

Ty Classic Memphis Hound Dog Plush Brown 15" Long Floppy Ears Soft Lay Down 2001

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

Ty Classic Hatcher Chick Plush Stuffed Animal 14" 2005 Heart Tag Attached

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

Ty Classic Dash Tiger 1999 Vintage With Tag

$ 12.32 $ 7.39

TY Beanie Buddy Classic Plush GLORIA the Angel Bear 12"

$ 20.23 $ 12.13

TY Classic 2001 Godzilla White Eyes for Japan ONLY

$ 52.8 $ 31.67

Ty Classic 2002 White Cat Kitty Kitten Blue Eye Crystal Pink Ribbon Bow

$ 35.19 $ 21.11

TY Classic Plush Pink Teddy Bear "Sugarplum" with Pink, Yellow & Blue Tie Bow

$ 4.35 $ 2.61

TY Classic Plush CROCKETT Bear NEW 2003 Release Retired Brown Soft Cream Bow Tie

$ 21.99 $ 13.19

Ty Plush Flip Beanie Buddy White Cat Pink Bow Blue Eyes With Tag Buddies

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

Rare Retired 2006 Ty Classic Dog STUBBS 14" Stuffed Plush - NWT

$ 16.67 $ 10

TY Mischief White Monkey Vintage Korea 1987 Stuffed Animal Toy Plush 2nd Gen

$ 26.35 $ 15.81

Ty Classic Silk 2007 Slush Husky Dog Wolf Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 10" With Tag

$ 26.39 $ 15.83

Ty Classic Goldwyn Plush Golden Lab Retriever Puppy Dog Plaid Bow 2007

$ 13.2 $ 7.91

TY Floppy Classic Onyx Black Persian Cat 16” Plush Stuffed Animal 2000 Realistic

$ 15.79 $ 9.47

IN STOCK #100 Factory Direct“Original BTP / Beanie Babies Style Tag Protectors.

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

Vintage Stuffed Animals Chick 9" Retired Yellow Plush Peep TY 2005 FLUFFY

$ 13.42 $ 8.05

Ty Classic Pepper Puppy 10" Plush Dog Black Brown Stuffed Animal Vintage 1996

$ 16.71 $ 10.02

Ty Classic Silk Beanie Baby Hudson Bear Plush Red Hat Stuffed Tan 14” 2006 EUC

$ 12.31 $ 7.38

Ty Classic Chaucer Bear Borders Exclusive 2008 Plush 15" Stuffed Animal Scarf

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

TY 1994 Plush Large Black Puppy Dog CINDERS Stuffed Animal Toy 14" Retired HTF

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

TY Classic Toffee 14" Puppy Dog Plush 1999 Brown Tan Stuffed Animal Retired Tags

$ 30.79 $ 18.47

Vintage Ty Plush Bear Magee Bear 1998 Stuffed Animal Toy Brown 9 inch Classic

$ 4.4 $ 2.64

LEFTY--Ty Buddy--store new--never Played With

$ 4.35 $ 2.61

Salty "ANCHORS AWAY!" ~ 1993 TY Bears ~ Attic Treasures Collection ~ Set of 2

$ 8.52 $ 5.11

TY PRISSY THE CAT 1999 12" BROWN SITTING CAT PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL TOY NWOT

$ 16.28 $ 9.76

BACK IN STOCK #100 The Original BTP Brand) Beanie / Baby Style Tag Protectors.

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

Ty Classic MOLASSES Dark Brown Bear 14in Soft Fur Plush 2002 Brown Tan Plaid Bow

$ 14.95 $ 8.97

Ty Classic Bamboo Panda Bear 10" Plush Bean Bag Stuffed Toy Vintage 1997 w Tags

$ 19.75 $ 11.85

#100 NEW Original “BTP Brand “Large Heart TY Plush Tag Protectors

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

Ty Classic Elephant TEENSY Soft Plush Gray Floppy 20” 2002 Retired

$ 20.36 $ 12.21

Ty Classic 2006 Flags Teddy Bear 13" Bean Plush Patriotic American Stars Stripes

$ 8.79 $ 5.27

Ty Classic Sugarcoat Purple Shaggy Teddy Bear Plush Ribbon Bow 13" with tags

$ 5.28 $ 3.16

TY Classic Plush BAMBOO Panda Bear Vintage MINT

$ 14.08 $ 8.44

Lot of 2 TY Beanie Babies Retired Baby PJ and Classic Crockett With Tags R

$ 13.2 $ 7.91

Ty Classic Nibbles Brown Stuffed Plush Bunny Rabbit 1993 8"

$ 4.39 $ 2.63

#100 BTP (Brand) Beanie Babies (Baby )Tag protectors. Mitchell’s Direct !

$ 13.19 $ 7.91

Ty Classic Bamboo The Panda Retired 14” Tall Mint With Mint Tags

$ 7.92 $ 4.75

Ty Classic SLUSH Siberian Husky Wolf Puppy Dog 10" Plush TySilk 2007 Stuffed

$ 17.59 $ 10.55

Ty Classic Barley Puppy Dog Tan White Plush Stuffed Animal 2009 Toy Plushie

$ 26.65 $ 15.99